Where this came from
This started several years ago with my friend Matt. We both love making cookies, and we both dread what comes after the first round of cutting: the scraps. You gather them up, roll them out again, cut a few more, then gather what is left and do it all over again. By the third or fourth roll the dough is warmer and tougher than when you started, and the cookies are never quite as good as the first batch.
So we asked a simple question: what if the cookies fit together? If a cutter’s shape tiles the way a bathroom floor does, each cut sits against the one before it, and there is hardly any dough left to re-roll. We wanted a tessellating cookie cutter.
We toyed with turning it into a Kickstarter, but it faltered, the way a lot of side projects do. The idea never really went away, though. All we ever wanted was for everybody to have infinite cookies in less time.
So here it is, finally: four designs you can print, and a way to see how much of your dough each one saves. Thanks, Matt.
Dough thickness
Roll to 6 mm, which is about ¼ inch. The cutters are built around that number.
| Rolled thickness | Cut through | Emboss depth | What to expect |
| 3–4 mm | Yes | None | Thin, crisp cookies. The ridges barely touch the dough, so the embossed pattern will not show. |
| 5 mm | Yes | 1 mm | Light pattern. Good if you like a thinner cookie. |
| 6 mm ★ | Yes | 2 mm | The design target: a clear pattern and a soft middle. |
| 7 mm | Yes | 3 mm | Deep pattern. The dough around the ridges gets squeezed, so go gently. |
| 8 mm and up | Yes | 4 mm+ | Not recommended. The ridges crush half the dough, and it tends to tear when you lift the cutter. |
The cutting wall stands 16 mm tall and the ridges stop 4 mm above the cutting edge. Emboss depth is the dough thickness minus 4 mm.
Roll it even. A tessellated sheet has no spare dough to hide a thin patch. Use rolling-pin guide rings or a pair of 6 mm strips on either side of the dough, and roll until the pin rides on them.
Chill it first. Cold, firm dough cuts cleanly and holds the pattern. If it softens while you work, slide the sheet onto a tray and back into the fridge for a few minutes.
Start in a corner. Press the first cutter 5 mm in from the edge. Set each next press so its wall sits on the line the last one left, and press straight down. The tree, house and present pyramid need every other cookie turned 180°, as shown on the sheet above. The snowflake needs no turning.
Lift, don’t drag. Slide a thin spatula under each cookie and move it to the pan with room around it, because the cookies are cut touching and will fuse if baked that way.